Playbook #15Leadership8 min read

How to set core values for a moving company.

If you read Part 1, you have a mission and a vision. If you skipped it, go back, because nothing here works without them. For most owners this is their first business, and nobody ever explained why any of this matters. It feels like something for big companies with boardrooms.

The mission is the roof. This part builds the columns that hold it up: the behaviors every person in the company either lives by or leaves over. Not guidelines, not suggestions. The lines that don’t bend. Core values.

Where values come from

After Part 1 you may have thought: fine, I wrote a mission statement, now what? It still feels abstract. That’s normal. Part 2 is where it starts to click, and Part 3 is where it clicks completely. Right now you’re about halfway to a system that runs the company.

Core values are not a separate exercise from the mission. They come out of it. Take your mission and vision and ask one question:

What behavior does my mission demand from every person in this company?

You’re not inventing a new personality for the business here. You’re finding what is already there, the way you already make decisions, and putting a system around it so it survives without you in the room.

These are going to have consequences

In Part 3 these values turn into competencies, and competencies get enforced. Every time, with every person, no exceptions. You can’t apply a value selectively.

If you write accountability as a value, you will one day let your top salesperson go for not being accountable. If you’re not willing to do that, don’t write it down.

How to discover yours

Start with how you already behave under pressure. How do you compromise? In a crisis, what decides it? What do you refuse to bend on even when bending would make you money?

If you look honestly and find you’re not consistent, that is the bigger problem, and it’s worth knowing now. People can see it. When the rules can go either way depending on the day, the team plays it that way.

  1. Ask what you'd never compromise on

    Even if it costs you a job, a client, or your best salesperson. If you'd give it up to save the company, it was a preference, not a value.

  2. Stop at five

    Everyone has to be able to remember them without a cheat sheet. If you need a card in your wallet to recall your own values, they're a wish list.

  3. Check each one against the mission

    Every value should trace back to a line in your mission or vision. If you can't say which line forced it, it probably came from someone else's website.

The line you don't cross

A core value holds even on the brink of bankruptcy. That’s the test. If you would abandon it to keep the lights on, it was never a value.

Look at what you tolerate, not what you say

This is the honest version of the exercise, and it’s the one most owners skip. Forget what’s on the poster. Look at what actually happens in the company this week.

“Look at what you tolerate, not what you say.” Rodney Warner

You say ownership

But a manager who blames everyone else keeps his job

Your real value is: it’s fine to blame others. That is what the team has learned, whatever the wall says.

You say quality

But you rush jobs to close more of them

Your real value is: volume over quality. The crews know it, and they pack accordingly.

When what you tolerate contradicts what you wrote, one of them has to change. Either the behavior goes or the value goes. A value nobody enforces is worse than no value at all, because it teaches the team that words here mean nothing.

How two movers built theirs

The industry is full of companies with copied mission statements and copied values, the same way they copy each other’s emails and pricing. Nobody connects them to anything. That’s why they all look the same. Here are two that did it differently: every value traces back to something real.

JK Moving Services

Vision: “To be the best, for our customers, our employees, and our community.”

Three words did the work: customers, employees, community. Not just profit. All three. That forced everything underneath.

  1. “Best for our customers” forced Ownership

    Best means the job gets done right, on time, within budget. When something goes wrong, you fix it. You don't point at someone else. A company where people point fingers can't be the best.

  2. “Best” forced Raise the Bar

    Best isn't a finish line. What's best today is average tomorrow, so everyone is expected to take on challenges, not just accept them. You can't stay the best by staying comfortable.

  3. “Best for our employees” forced Commit to Growth

    Best for your people is more than a paycheck. It means they get better every year. Every person is expected to learn and add skills, with no exceptions.

  4. “Community” forced something most companies skip

    Most companies write community into the vision and do nothing. JK's founder, Chuck Kuhn, built a 150-acre nonprofit farm on his own land that grows organic food and gives all of it to children, seniors, and families facing hunger. Not a check to a charity. A farm. Because the vision said community and he meant it.

Two Men and a Truck

Mission: “Continuously strive to exceed our customers’ expectations in value and high standard of satisfaction.”

Notice the wording. Not “be the best” but “continuously strive to exceed.” That’s a different mission with different consequences. “Be the best” pushes you to hire only top performers and cut anyone who falls short. “Strive to exceed” pushes you to care, to try harder, to never settle for just okay. It’s a warmer mission, and it produced warmer values.

  1. “Exceed expectations” forced the Grandma Rule

    In moving, expectations are low. Customers expect things to break and calls to go unanswered. So what does exceeding that look like? Treat people the way you'd want your grandmother treated: with patience, care, and respect. Not “be professional.” Grandma. That's a feeling, not a standard.

  2. “High standard of satisfaction” forced Integrity

    No hidden surprises, no fine print that moves the price, no excuses when something goes wrong. You can't exceed expectations while misleading people about what to expect.

  3. Who the founder was forced Give Back

    This one didn't come from the mission statement. It came from a moment. At the end of her first year, Mary Ellen Sheets made $1,000 in profit and gave all of it away: ten nonprofits, $100 each. She had almost nothing and gave it all. That set the standard from day one. The franchises combined have since donated over $260 million to their communities.

The pattern

Every time, the mission forces the values. The values force how managers behave. The behavior forces what you hire for and what you fire for.

A vague mission forces nothing, so the values are vague, so the behavior is inconsistent, so the culture is whatever happens. A specific mission forces specific values, and specific values force specific behavior. That is a company. Everything else is a group of people showing up.

Your turn

Take the mission and vision you wrote in Part 1 and read it again. Then work through this, on paper, not in your head.

  1. Ask what behavior it demands

    For each line of the mission, what does it require from every person here? Write the behaviors down before you name them.

  2. Ask what you'd never compromise on

    Even if it costs you money. Even if it means losing your best salesperson. Those are the candidates.

  3. Cut to five or fewer

    Make them real and make them yours. If any of them came from another company's website, throw them out and start again.

  4. Walk the building

    Look at what you tolerate today. Where the tolerated behavior contradicts a value, decide which one changes. You can't keep both.

Before you move on

If the honest answer to “do we live these?” is no, the work starts before Part 3. Close the gap between what you say and what you tolerate first. Competencies built on top of values nobody enforces crack the first time they’re tested.

The short version

  • Core values come out of the mission. Ask: what behavior does my mission demand from every person here?
  • A value is something you'd enforce on your top salesperson. If you wouldn't, don't write it.
  • No more than five. If you can't remember them, nobody else will.
  • A value you'd abandon to avoid bankruptcy was a preference, not a value.
  • Your real values are what you tolerate, not what you say. Fix the gap or drop the value.
  • JK Moving: customers → Ownership, best → Raise the Bar, employees → Commit to Growth, community → a 150-acre nonprofit farm.
  • Two Men and a Truck: exceed expectations → the Grandma Rule, high standard → Integrity, the founder's first $1,000 → Give Back.
  • Write yours on paper, then walk the company and check whether you live them before moving to Part 3.

Next in the series

Part 3 turns these values into competencies: written expectations by role and seniority that you hire against, review against, and let people go against. This is where the whole system clicks. Read Part 3: competencies.

Not ready for a diagnostic? Read this month’s Playbook.

Read